Now of course I don't, and can't, watch everything on TV. So this is my opinion based on what I have been watching. I did start off the fall TV season with 23 shows on the roster, so I dare say it's at least relatively comprehensive.
Best new comedy - Brooklyn 99
Funny and smart, I fear this comedy may go the way of many of my other favorites (RIP 30 Rock). Andy Samberg is the clear star, but I enjoy the many funny lady cops who back him up.
Best new drama - The Blacklist
While the serial aspect of the show can get a little tedious, the big picture plot is supremely intriguing. Also James Spader is genius in it.
Best returning comedy - The Mindy Project
I have a serious girl crush on Mindy Kaling and this show is hitting its sweet spot with new characters and lots of charm.
Best returning drama - Scandal
If you work in an office with at least two female co-workers, someone is talking about this show on Friday mornings. It just keeps getting juicer, flashier, and more outrageous and I can't get enough.
New shows to drop
Hostages - This show might look shinier if it didn't have to compete with The Blacklist in the same slot. Unfortunately, it just pales in comparison.
Super Fun Night - I wanted to like this show, but it just wasn't funny and I like my female characters to be, well, more than just characters (see: Mindy Project.)
Returning shows to drop
New Girl - If Nick and Jess don't make you gag, you may need to see a doctor. This crew just needs to grow up already.
Glee - What is the plot/point of this show again?
Sad to see it go
Breaking Bad - It was epic.
Excited for its return
Portlandia - Should be mandatory for anyone living in hipster meccas including Portland, Austin, and Brooklyn. Let's hope they start off season four with a new "Dream of the 90's" ballad.
The Following - Season one is on Netflix so get on it. The creepy quotient is high and getting higher. Like the best episodes of Criminal Minds, but so much better.